Driving · 2026-11-10

Deploying Physically and Epistemically Compliant Agents by Distilling Belief-Space Task and Motion Planners

Phillip J. K. Christoffersen, Rachel Ma, Patrick Barrag\'an, Dylan Hadfield-Menell

arXiv:2611.10430PDF

AI-assisted summary based on the paper. Consult the linked source for methods and limitations. Benchmark numbers appear after editor verification.

TL;DR

The authors train policies to comply with belief-dependent task rules by offline distillation of belief-space task-and-motion planners. They adapt planner imitation for history-based policies using Dual Averaging and ρ-Optimal Reinforcement. They show completeness conditions for static search under noiseless observation models and evaluate in the new Scavenger domain. The distilled policy achieves success above 90%, versus at most 5% for reward-engineered RL, and transfers to unseen vague language commands and larger floorplans.

Why it matters

The paper targets a deployment gap: belief-space planning is compliant by construction but engineering-heavy under partial observability, while RL can fail to perfectly optimize reward-encoded specifications. By distilling belief-space plans into policies that act on raw observations (without online belief estimation), and by adding training losses/feedback tailored to history-based policies, the authors propose a practical route to agents that satisfy physically and epistemically compliant behavior under uncertainty.

Method

  • Offline planner-to-policy distillation: generate sample trajectories with a belief-space task and motion planner in simulation, then train a policy that acts on raw observations.
  • Dual Averaging: modify the high-level imitation loss to average per-timestep loss and also average loss over timesteps when the task planner changes actions, improving training for history-dependent policies.
  • ρ-Optimal Reinforcement: compare policy successes to successful planned trajectories and add near-optimal trajectories to the dataset when the policy rollout length is within a factor ρ of the planner, otherwise push the planner trajectory.

Limitation

The authors assume a tractable model is available for belief-space planning; they note this is reasonable with access to a simulator, but “exploring how to move past this is interesting future work.”

Abstract (from arXiv)

In this work, we train agents to act under uncertainty according to specified, belief-dependent rules. Deep reinforcement learning (RL) can in theory train agents to follow rules if encoded into well-designed rewards, but in practice, RL fails to perfectly optimize these rewards, leading to ineffective or noncompliant agent behavior. Belief-space planners by construction produce behavior in line with developer specification, but require hand-programming online planners and belief-state estimators, adding significant engineering complexity at scale. We combine the two: we plan offline to generate a dataset of sample trajectories and then distill the plans into a policy that acts on raw observations. We propose two changes to planner distillation that address problems specific to history-based policies: Dual Averaging, a loss that combines per-timestep predictive loss and average loss on task changes, and $\rho$-Optimal Reinforcement, a feedback mechanism that reinforces the policy's own successful rollouts when these are near-optimal. We provide a sufficient condition under which static search problems with noiseless observation models is complete, and show that maximum-likelihood-observation planning implies this condition in static search with continuous beliefs. We create a challenging new domain, Scavenger, where an agent needs to gain information in order to succeed. We evaluate our distilled policy in two versions of Scavenger, one where information is provided visually and one where it is provided as a command in natural language. In either case, the learned policy attains a success rate above 90% in Scavenger, compared with at most 5% for RL. We also find that distilled planners transfer with greater than 60% success to following unseen and intentionally vague commands and greater than 75% success to following floorplans larger than those seen in training.

Related papers

Publication record

Bibliographic evidence describes where and when a record appeared. It does not validate scientific claims.

First announced by arXiv: 2026-11-10 · Indexed by Pub-AI: 2026-11-10 UTC

preprint

Deploying Physically and Epistemically Compliant Agents by Distilling Belief-Space Task and Motion Planners

Phillip J. K. Christoffersen, Rachel Ma, Patrick Barrag\'an, Dylan Hadfield-Menell

First announced by arXiv: 2026-11-10 · Original record ↗

arxiv
2611.10430
Explicit source versions (1)
  • v1 · Date not supplied
  1. Preprint available

    Source date: 2026-11-10 · First detected: 2026-11-10 UTC · Historical baseline

    Source evidence (1)
    • Official evidence ↗ · RSS guid=oai:arXiv.org:2611.10430v1; arxiv:announce_type=new; item pubDate (official metadata)
Abstract · arxiv

In this work, we train agents to act under uncertainty according to specified, belief-dependent rules. Deep reinforcement learning (RL) can in theory train agents to follow rules if encoded into well-designed rewards, but in practice, RL fails to perfectly optimize these rewards, leading to ineffective or noncompliant agent behavior. Belief-space planners by construction produce behavior in line with developer specification, but require hand-programming online planners and belief-state estimators, adding significant engineering complexity at scale. We combine the two: we plan offline to generate a dataset of sample trajectories and then distill the plans into a policy that acts on raw observations. We propose two changes to planner distillation that address problems specific to history-based policies: Dual Averaging, a loss that combines per-timestep predictive loss and average loss on task changes, and $\rho$-Optimal Reinforcement, a feedback mechanism that reinforces the policy's own successful rollouts when these are near-optimal. We provide a sufficient condition under which static search problems with noiseless observation models is complete, and show that maximum-likelihood-observation planning implies this condition in static search with continuous beliefs. We create a challenging new domain, Scavenger, where an agent needs to gain information in order to succeed. We evaluate our distilled policy in two versions of Scavenger, one where information is provided visually and one where it is provided as a command in natural language. In either case, the learned policy attains a success rate above 90% in Scavenger, compared with at most 5% for RL. We also find that distilled planners transfer with greater than 60% success to following unseen and intentionally vague commands and greater than 75% success to following floorplans larger than those seen in training.